Response to an Article Criticizing 401(k) Plans

If your retirement plan advisor cannot clearly tell you how many hours were spent on your account last year, you are not participating in a market. You are operating inside a system intentionally structured so that question never needs to be answered.

Most business owners assume their 401(k) fees are reasonable because the plan has been benchmarked, the advisor is a fiduciary, or the plan is audited. Each of these provides reassurance, but none establish price discipline. Benchmarking compares prices without defining services. Fiduciary status governs process, not cost. Audits confirm compliance, not whether the dollars paid reflect the work performed.

This mini book explains why retirement plans never developed the mechanics required for a functioning market and why disclosure alone cannot correct the problem. Services are not invoiced. Fees are rarely expressed in dollar terms tied to actual labor. And there is no recurring moment where costs must be justified or where renewal can be meaningfully declined.

When a $3 million plan pays a 0.50 percent advisory fee, that equals $15,000 per year. If assets grow to $5 million with no change in service, the fee becomes $25,000. The work did not increase. The price did. And no bill was ever sent.

Even when fees are disclosed and reduced, rational pricing often still fails to emerge. The obstacles are not informational but behavioral, institutional, and structural. Drawing on 17 years of reviewing regulatory filings and reconstructing opaque fee arrangements, this analysis shows why transparency repeatedly falls short, why percentage-based reductions feel corrective even when remaining costs are indefensible, and why administrators, recordkeepers, and advisors are systematically discouraged from challenging excess fees.

The conclusion is not that new regulation is needed. It is that markets require an actor whose incentives align with scrutiny, and that role does not exist in the retirement plan system today. What is missing, why it matters, and what a truly accountable pricing structure would look like are the focus of this mini book.